On Could 20, 2021, President Biden signed an Executive Order on Climate-Related Financial Risk, which outlines varied initiatives to advertise insurance policies associated to bodily and transition dangers related to local weather change and to prioritize federal investments in help of these insurance policies. On this alert, we deal with key elements of the order that might have implications for personal fairness funds and areas of consideration for asset managers as an entire.
The Government Order addresses 5 broad priorities:
develop a government-wide technique for mitigating climate-related monetary danger;
encourage monetary regulators to evaluate climate-related monetary danger;
encourage consideration of climate-related monetary dangers associated to life financial savings and pensions;
modernize federal lending, underwriting and procurement practices by incorporating climate-related monetary dangers; and
cut back the danger of local weather change to the federal funds.
Varied federal entities are directed to develop methods and put together stories in furtherance of those objectives. Whereas the Government Order has no instant influence on the foundations governing monetary markets, it indicators a shift in federal priorities that might create alternatives for personal fairness sooner or later.
Implications of the Government Order for Personal Fairness
Local weather-Associated Monetary Danger Technique
The Government Order requires growth of a government-wide local weather danger technique. The technique should deal with the measurement, evaluation, mitigation, and disclosure of climate-related monetary danger to federal authorities packages, belongings, and liabilities. The technique additionally should establish financing wants related to attaining net-zero greenhouse gasoline emissions for the U.S. financial system by 2050 and alternatives for private and non-private investments to fulfill these financing wants. The Director of the Nationwide Financial Council and the Nationwide Local weather Advisor should coordinate with the Secretary of the Treasury and the Director of the Workplace of Administration and Price range to develop the technique by September 17, 2021 (120 days after the date of the Government Order).
Such a broad-based climate-risk technique might current alternatives for personal fairness to focus on firms that may contribute to the aim of attaining net-zero greenhouse gasoline emissions by 2050. Based on 2019 figures launched by the Environmental Safety Company, the totality of United States greenhouse gasoline emissions could be traced to 5 sectors: transportation, electrical energy technology, trade, business & residential, and agriculture. These 5 sectors are answerable for 29%, 25%, 23%, 13% and 10% of nationwide greenhouse gasoline emissions, respectively. Within the industrial sector alone, the cement and metal industries every contribute roughly 8% to international greenhouse gasoline emissions.
Local weather-related innovation in all 5 of those sectors is rising quickly, aided by substantial development in personal fairness funding in expertise firms which have developed, or are within the strategy of creating, carbon-neutral or much less carbon-intensive alternate options to actions which might be historically carbon-intensive. For instance, quite a few funds search to speculate particularly in environmental and cleantech firms with the potential to scale back greenhouse gasoline emissions by modern applied sciences. As well as, BlackRock and Vanguard lately grew to become signatories of the Internet Zero Asset Managers Initiative, which unites asset managers across the aim of attaining web zero emissions by 2050 or sooner. These funding methods and commitments are aligned with the objectives of a federal climate-related monetary technique, and personal fairness funds with related approaches needs to be well-positioned to benefit from any new alternatives that come up from the Government Order.
Potential Influence on Pension Funds
The Government Order directs the Secretary of Labor to take a number of actions that might facilitate extra retirement plan investments in personal funding funds and different funding autos with methods that promote or deal with environmental, social and governance (ESG)-related objectives. The Government Order features a basic directive to establish company actions that may very well be taken beneath the Worker Retirement Earnings Safety Act of 1974 (ERISA) and the Federal Workers’ Retirement System Act of 1986 to guard retirement financial savings and pensions from the threats of climate-related monetary danger. Moreover, the Government Order directs the Secretary of Labor to contemplate proposing a rule, by September 2021, to droop, revise, or rescind two ESG-related guidelines adopted by the Division of Labor (DOL) beneath the Trump administration (the “2020 guidelines”). The 2020 guidelines typically require ERISA plan fiduciaries to make plan funding and proxy voting choices based mostly solely on consideration of “pecuniary components” and prohibit them from making such choices based mostly on non-pecuniary concerns (e.g., ESG sort components) besides in very restricted circumstances. Partly as a result of the 2020 guidelines (and confusion in regards to the 2020 guidelines) had a chilling impact on the suitable integration of ESG components in ERISA plan funding choices, the DOL introduced in March that it could not implement the 2020 guidelines till additional steerage is issued. However the DOL’s non-enforcement assertion, the 2020 guidelines haven’t truly been rescinded, and extra rulemaking might present some welcome readability on these points.
Rescinding or considerably revising the 2020 guidelines might mitigate confusion and fears surrounding investing based mostly on ESG components and objectives and encourage extra ERISA plan fiduciaries to include ESG investments into their portfolios. Nonetheless, the character and influence of any future DOL motion is unknown at the moment. The Government Order additionally directs the DOL to submit a report back to the President on its actions in response to the Government Order inside 180 days, so we could have extra perception into the DOL’s path by November of this yr.
Evaluation of Local weather-Associated Monetary Danger by Monetary Regulators
The Government Order directs the Monetary Stability Oversight Council (FSOC) to contemplate taking various actions, together with issuing a report on any efforts by FSOC member businesses to combine consideration of climate-related monetary danger into their insurance policies and packages. This report would talk about, amongst different issues, the need of any actions to reinforce climate-related disclosures by regulated entities to scale back climate-related monetary danger to the monetary system, and another suggestions for mitigating such danger by new or revised regulatory requirements. Though the order solely directs the FSOC to contemplate issuing the report, we anticipate to see a report that addresses most, if not all, of the subjects recognized within the Government Order by November 16, 2021, the deadline imposed within the order. The emphasis on climate-related disclosures is in step with efforts already underway on the SEC to develop proposals for obligatory local weather change disclosure necessities that may apply to public firms.
Federal Lending, Underwriting, and Procurement
The Government Order contains a number of directives associated to authorities contracting and lending by federal businesses. It seeks suggestions for the combination of climate-related monetary danger data into federal monetary administration and monetary reporting, particularly as that danger pertains to federal lending packages. The order additionally requires consideration of modifications to federal procurement guidelines that may (i) require main federal suppliers to publicly disclose greenhouse gasoline emissions and climate-related monetary danger, and (ii) give desire to suppliers with a decrease “social value” of greenhouse gasoline emissions. Moreover, federal businesses should combine climate-related monetary danger into their very own procurement processes. With the rise in infrastructure-focused personal fairness funds and the growth of funding mandates of current personal fairness funds, asset managers might want to comply with these potential regulatory modifications in reference to the event of their funding thesis and the evaluation of particular investments within the infrastructure vertical, distribution and procurement verticals and different ancillary verticals that work together with the federal authorities on a business foundation.
The Government Order doesn’t create any instantly enforceable guidelines, but it surely does chart a course for higher emphasis on climate-related danger concerns in federal monetary coverage. Stories which might be required or urged by the order will shed extra mild on the potential longer-term influence of this coverage shift on the monetary markets and controlled entities. Whereas most of the priorities coated by the order is not going to have an effect on the asset-management trade, we imagine that growth of a extra climate-focused federal monetary technique and potential associated modifications to the ERISA guidelines might create alternatives for personal fairness companies which might be ready to benefit from these shifts in coverage. Proskauer will proceed to trace vital regulatory modifications with a deal with the implications and alternatives for personal fairness funds, and we encourage asset managers to observe developments on this space.
 See White Home Briefing Room Truth Sheet: President Biden Directs Businesses to Analyze and Mitigate the Danger Local weather Change Poses to Householders and Customers, Companies and Staff, and the Monetary System and the Federal Authorities Itself, Could 20, 2021, accessible right here.
 See United States Environmental Safety Company, Sources of Greenhouse Fuel Emissions, accessible right here.
 See Chatham Home Report, Making Concrete Change: Innovation in Low-carbon Cement and Concrete, June 13, 2018, accessible right here.
 See McKinsey & Firm, Decarbonization problem for metal, June 3, 2020, accessible right here.
 Fiduciary Duties Concerning Proxy Voting and Shareholder Rights, 85 Fed. Reg. 81658 (December 16, 2020); Monetary Elements in Deciding on Plan Investments, 85 Fed. Reg. 72846 (November 13, 2020). Extra data concerning such guidelines is obtainable right here and right here.
 Extra data concerning such announcement is obtainable right here.
 FSOC member businesses embody: Division of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, Workplace of the Comptroller of the Foreign money, Shopper Monetary Safety Bureau, U.S. Securities and Change Fee, Federal Deposit Insurance coverage Company, Commodity Futures Buying and selling Fee, Federal Housing Finance Company, Nationwide Credit score Union Administration Board, Workplace of Monetary Analysis, and Federal Insurance coverage Workplace.
 See, e.g., SEC Request for Enter on Local weather Change Disclosures, accessible right here.
© 2021 Proskauer Rose LLP. Nationwide Regulation Overview, Quantity XI, Quantity 181